Bringing in an outside team to manage your public image is a big decision. We have spoken with plenty of business owners and professionals who rushed the process and later wished they had asked more questions up front.

Many of those problems are easy to avoid with a little preparation. Our friends at Goldman McCormick PR discuss what to look for in a public relations agency and why the right fit matters as much as the services offered. Below, we share the missteps we see most often, along with practical ways to avoid them.

Starting Without Clear Goals

Some people hire a PR firm because they feel they should, not because they know what they want. Do you need media coverage for a product launch? Help rebuilding trust after bad press? A steady flow of articles that position you as a trusted voice in your field?

Without defined goals, it’s hard to measure progress. It’s also easy to end up paying for work that doesn’t move you forward. Write down what success looks like before your first meeting.

Picking the Cheapest Option

Budget matters. Still, choosing an agency on price alone can backfire. A low monthly fee may come with limited attention, junior staff handling your account, or a one-size-fits-all strategy. Ask what is included, who will actually do the work, and how often you will hear from them.

Overlooking Relevant Experience

A firm that does great work promoting restaurants may not be the right choice for a medical practice or a company facing litigation. Every industry has its own audiences, sensitivities, and media contacts. Ask for examples of similar work and how those campaigns were handled.

Signing the Contract Without a Careful Review

This is where we see some of the most avoidable trouble. PR agreements vary widely, and vague terms often lead to disputes later. Before signing, look closely at:

  • The scope of services and what counts as extra work
  • Payment terms, retainers, and billing for outside costs
  • How and when either side can end the relationship
  • Who owns the content, press materials, and media lists created
  • Confidentiality obligations for sensitive business information

If any of these points are unclear, ask for changes in writing. A reputable agency should be comfortable explaining its terms.

Expecting Guaranteed Headlines

Good PR firms have strong media relationships, but no one controls what editors decide to publish. Be cautious of any agency that promises specific placements. Honest firms will explain their approach and set realistic expectations from the start.

Leaving Your Lawyer Out of Sensitive Matters

If you’re dealing with a lawsuit, a regulatory issue, or an internal investigation, public statements can carry legal consequences. A comment that seems harmless today could be used against you later. Conversations with a publicist may also not be protected the same way conversations with your attorney are.

When legal issues are involved, your attorney and PR team should coordinate on messaging before anything goes public.

Treating PR as a One-Time Fix

Reputation is built over time. A single press release or a short burst of activity rarely delivers lasting results. The strongest outcomes usually come from consistent effort, regular communication, and a willingness to adjust the plan as circumstances change.

Getting the Right Guidance Before You Commit

Hiring a PR firm can be a smart investment when you go in with clear goals and a solid agreement. If you have questions about a PR contract, how public statements might affect a legal matter, or how to protect your interests along the way, we encourage you to connect with an attorney who can offer guidance based on your situation.